Using Amendment V To Correct The “Progressive” Drift

Senator Tom Coburn is calling for it.

Long time readers will know that my preferred solution to our constitutional issues is to amend the Constitution per Article V. Mark Levin’s book,The Liberty Amendments, sets out one set of possibilities – but before that, Randy Barnett, an expert on constitutional law, proposed a Bill of Federalism back in 2009. I like both ideas – Barnett’s do make a little more sense to me:

Resolution for Congress to Convene a Convention to Propose Amendments Constituting a Bill of Federalism

Whereas Article I of the Constitution of the United States begins “All legislative powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States”; and

Whereas the Congress of the United States has exceeded the legislative powers granted in the Constitution thereby usurping the powers that are “reserved to the states respectively, or to the people” as the 10th Amendment affirms and the rights “retained by the people” to which the Ninth Amendment refers; and

Whereas the Supreme Court of the United States has ignored or misinterpreted the meaning of the Constitution by upholding this usurpation;

To restore a proper balance between the powers of Congress and those of the several States, and to prevent the denial or disparagement of the rights retained by the people, the legislature of the State of ________ hereby resolves:

First, that Congress shall call a convention, consisting of delegates from the several States selected by procedures established by their respective legislatures, for the purpose of proposing the following articles be added as separate amendments to the Constitution of the United States, each of which shall be valid to all intents and purposes as part of the Constitution when separately ratified by the legislatures of three-fourths of the several States; and

Second, that any previous memorial for a convention under Article V of the Constitution of the United States by this legislature is hereby repealed and without effect; and

Third, that copies of this memorial shall be sent to the secretary of state and presiding officers of both houses of the legislatures of each of the several states in the union, the clerk of the United States house of representatives, the secretary of the United States senate, and to each member of the ________ congressional delegation; and

Fourth, that this memorial for a convention is conditioned on the memorials of two-thirds of the legislatures of the several states proposing the exact same language contained in some or all of the following articles, and is to remain in effect unless repealed by resolution of this legislature prior to the memorials of two-thirds of the states being reported to Congress:

Article [of Amendment 1] — [Restrictions on Tax Powers of Congress]

Section 1. Congress shall make no law laying or collecting taxes upon incomes, gifts, or estates, or upon aggregate consumption or expenditures; but Congress shall have power to levy a uniform tax on the sale of goods or services.

Section 2. Any imposition of or increase in a tax, duty, impost or excise shall require the approval of three-fifths of the House of Representatives and three-fifths of the Senate, and shall separately be presented to the president of the United States.

Section 3. This article shall be effective five years from the date of its ratification, at which time the 16th Article of amendment is repealed.

Article [of Amendment 2] — [Limits of Commerce Power]

The power of Congress to make all laws which are necessary and proper to regulate commerce among the several states, or with foreign nations, shall not be construed to include the power to regulate or prohibit any activity that is confined within a single state regardless of its effects outside the state, whether it employs instrumentalities therefrom, or whether its regulation or prohibition is part of a comprehensive regulatory scheme; but Congress shall have power to regulate harmful emissions between one state and another, and to define and provide for punishment of offenses constituting acts of war or violent insurrection against the United States.

Article [of Amendment 3] — [Unfunded Mandates and Conditions on Spending]

Congress shall not impose upon a State, or political subdivision thereof, any obligation or duty to make expenditures unless such expenditures shall be fully reimbursed by the United States; nor shall Congress place any condition on the expenditure or receipt of appropriated funds requiring a State, or political subdivision thereof, to enact a law or regulation restricting the liberties of its citizens.

Article [of Amendment 4] — [No Abuse of the Treaty Power]

No treaty or other international agreement may enlarge the legislative power of Congress granted by this Constitution, nor govern except by legislation any activity that is confined within the United States.

Article [of Amendment 5] — [Freedom of Political Speech and Press]

The freedom of speech and press includes any contribution to political campaigns or to candidates for public office; and shall be construed to extend equally to any medium of communication however scarce.

Article [of Amendment 6] — [Power of States to Check Federal Power]

Upon the identically worded resolutions of the legislatures of three quarters of the states, any law or regulation of the United States, identified with specificity, is thereby rescinded.

Article [of Amendment 7] — [Term Limits for Congress]

No person who has served as a Senator for more than nine years, or as a Representative for more than eleven years, shall be eligible for election or appointment to the Senate or the House of Representatives respectively, excluding any time served prior to the enactment of this Article.

Article [of Amendment 8] — [Balanced Budget Line Item Veto]

Section 1. The budget of the United States shall be deemed unbalanced whenever the total amount of the public debt of the United States at the close of any fiscal year is greater than the total amount of such debt at the close of the preceding fiscal year.

Section 2. Whenever the budget of the United States is unbalanced, the President may, during the next annual session of Congress, separately approve, reduce or disapprove any monetary amounts in any legislation that appropriates or authorizes the appropriation of any money drawn from the Treasury, other than money for the operation of the Congress and judiciary of the United States.

Section 3. Any legislation that the President approves with changes pursuant to the second section of this Article shall become law as modified. The President shall return with objections those portions of the legislation containing reduced or disapproved monetary amounts to the House where such legislation originated, which may then, in the manner prescribed in the seventh section of the first Article of this Constitution, separately reconsider each reduced or disapproved monetary amount.

Section 4. The Congress shall have power to implement this Article by appropriate legislation; and this Article shall take effect on the first day of the next annual session of Congress following its ratification.

Article [of Amendment 9] — [The Rights Retained by the People]

Section 1. All persons are equally free and independent, and have certain natural, inherent and unalienable rights which they retain when forming any government, amongst which are the enjoying, defending and preserving of their life and liberty, acquiring, possessing and protecting real and personal property, making binding contracts of their choosing, and pursuing their happiness and safety.

Section 2. The due process of law shall be construed to provide the opportunity to introduce evidence or otherwise show that a law, regulation or order is an infringement of such rights of any citizen or legal resident of the United States, and the party defending the challenged law, regulation, or order shall have the burden of establishing the basis in law and fact of its conformity with this Constitution.

Article [of Amendment 10] — [Neither Foreign Law nor American Judges May Alter the Meaning of Constitution]

The words and phrases of this Constitution shall be interpreted according to their meaning at the time of their enactment, which meaning shall remain the same until changed pursuant to Article V; nor shall such meaning be altered by reference to the law of nations or the laws of other nations.

What do you think?

5 thoughts on “Using Amendment V To Correct The “Progressive” Drift

  1. It’s not likely there are enough disgruntled white protestant males to entice the calling of a convention. The present document seems to be protecting the rights of the property holding minority as intended.
    There’s a tremendous difference between being a member of the leisure class, belonging to the bourgeois or working class and being poor. The bourgeois can stomp their feet and pound their chests for eternity to protect the leisure class in an effort to advance their self interests achieving the same results that history has recorded for the past half a millennium. One might get to the table as a guest: full membership is a right not afforded to the common man regardless of one’s self-imposed image of success and influence.
    There is, however, conquest as an avenue. Good luck with that!

  2. Last Night while Talking together on Mark Levin’s show Randy and Mark were pretty Complimentary of BOTH their approaches. Levin uses Barnetts ideas in his book.

    One of the important points discussed and agreed on by BOTH Levin and Barnett is that Congress will not enact ANY laws that curtails Federal; Gov’t power…………. Thus Citizen support ( grass Roots) via the States will have to be the vector of change. To this point Barnett mentioned we have 27 Republican state legislatures now even WITHOUT such a movement being in full sway. So Barnett was hopeful of a STATES movement.

    There is a BIG difference between a “Constitutional Convention” and and “Amendments Convention “.

    In the first…. the Porogressives of Both Parties have a good chance of taking control .
    In the “Amendment Convention”….the States retain the power and the push for the Amendments Proposed is generated by the People via their Home states……. Congress is thus compelled to Call the Convention but doesn’t control the Process !!

    VERY BIG Difference !!!

    • Additionally Barnett also said last Night that the Constitution had already been changed for the worse by two Processes….
      (1) Officially….as in the 16th and 17th Amendment which both altered the Structure of Gov’t and the Intention of the Constitution………16th…Income Tax….17th…Election of Senators.
      —-while he liked and agreed with some of the Amendments like the 14th….others had been pushed by Congress an had undermined the Constitution ( hence Congress won’t change anything that REDUCES its power).
      (2) UNOFFICIAL changes to the Conetitution via the Courts…..which is the “Legislation from the Bench” issue….and is Unconstitutional.

      He and Mark also talked about the abuse of power and the assuming of power via the “Commerce Clause” to encompass “Civil Rights” and assumimg that Congress has the ability to Control the Entire Economy as a way to ensure “Civil Rights”……..Powers NEVER intended nor given in the Constitution.

      I think we have to understand that there will HAVE to be ROLLBACK on powers that Congress has today…..powers it has over time assumed unconstitutionally for itself…………..Thus any Amendment Convention will also HAVE to defended and its results strongly fought for……it will not be done merely by passing any legislation…..we have to unravel the Leviathon…..or it ios all jhust words on a page.

      And the Gov’t will continue to do what it does now…….Ignores and Trashes the Constitution and makes up its own laws as it goes along…….which I think is Really the Hallmark of the Obama Regime ….(and yes there is precident on both sides….but it is ramped up since 2007-2013)

  3. The Article V process for amendments will indeed be used when we become desperate enough. But a prerequisite for correction is not just the realization, but a deep conviction, of moral wrongdoing. The practical effects of the wrongs that have been done in violating the Constitution will bring this on us. Our societal complacency must meet with a life-threatening breakdown of our economy and/or infrastructure. The self-centered, leisure-oriented lifestyle must be interrupted to such an extent that not just the government-dependent welfare recipients, but also the ‘middle class’ and the rich, are faced with real physical need.
    It must become widely realized that people in and around government have not merely failed, they are morally culpable for the disaster.Much blame must fall upon academia and the media for the loss of a once-strong moral compass. We have been flaunting our vulnerability like a matador, before a jealous world which lacks the character that Americans showed 200 years ago. And, how far we have fallen! The only moral training we as a nation offer the world is now our violent and pornographic movies and videos. We are training those who will bring upon us the breakdown we need to correct ourselves, and our government. Then after we get back above the struggle-for-subsistence level, we will be able to see more clearly what amendments are needed to better protect the nation from the inevitable appearance of sinful personalities in the governmental machinery (and there will be a lot less of the machinery). More at

  4. I love it, but I do believe my boy Bill’s got a point. On the one hand, you have federal employees and FSA who would be threatened. There is a 50/50 divide as I see it. It shall be interesting to see if and how this should play out…..

Talk Amongst Yourselves:

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.