As Compared to Which Mythical Utopia?

I don’t know how to do this without sounding like a racist – but as I keep hearing that America is a horrible, racist place and according to some, owes reparations because the very founding of America was a racist act, I know of only one way to measure what America has truly become – and that is to compare (in today’s terms) America to the countries in Africa from which slaves came.

This is not a claim that slavery was a positive situation – but it happened and the past cannot be changed – all we can do now is to compare the progress – both social and economic – since slavery ended in America to the same elements of progress in those origin countries.

According to research, most of the slaves in America came from what are now the African countries of Senegal, Gambia, Guinea-Bissau and Mali; and west-central Africa, including what is now Angola, Congo, the Democratic Republic of Congo, as well as Ghana and the Ivory Coast.

Assume that there had been no slave trade and no Africans were brought to the US. Compare the economic and social conditions of those nine African countries to the conditions of slave descendants in America today.

In the period since slavery was exterminated in America, slavery in these countries continued to exist, frequent coups and war continued, corruption and poverty has reigned and tribal conflicts and genocide have continued.

Let’s also keep in mind that while we are constantly lectured about how much more enlightened Europe is than Americans, many of these African countries remained colonies of those same “enlightened” Europeans, not gaining independence until the 1960’s and 1970’s.

America is generally thought of as the driving force in the slave trade – but America accounted for roughly 3.6% of the slaves transported to the New World (about 388,000 people).

I am not trying to excuse the institution of slavery. If I could go back in time and change American history, that would be one of the things I would change – but when I hear people complain that America is bad, my first thought is “Bad as compared to what?”

I think it is disingenuous to compare contemporary America to some mythical Utopia or hypothetical standard that has never existed – it is much more legitimate to compare it to the best objective standards that exist in historical reality.

To be objective, we have to ask the painful, uncomfortable and politically incorrect question, “What would be the status of any given contemporary American black citizen if they were still resident in the origin country of their ancestors?”

And since that is a question of evaluation, not one of excuses, we actually need to ask that question of every racial and ethnic group in America today.
If honestly answer those questions, today’s America looks pretty good.


3 thoughts on “As Compared to Which Mythical Utopia?

  1. I am under the impression that when slaves were sold to Americans, slaves were being sold worldwide. If that is true we need to recognize America as simply one place where it was happening and not as the only racist country that put African people in slavery. It obviously was not happening in my lifetime so I can only react to what I have been taught. Also I have been taught that all slave owners here were not vicious or evil acting to their slaves. I also was taught that after slaves were freed in America, many or most of them continued to live and work for their previous owners.

  2. only 6-7 % of African slaves ( sold by their own people and muslim arabs) ever made it to the Colonies. The vast majority ( 68% ) where bought and imported by South America the rest were distributed between Central America and the Caribbean .
    Thus MOST African Slaves were purchased by SPANISH colonies…..Not British ones.

    • But Utah is correct only 3.6 made it to the mainland…..and similarly roughly the same amount to British Caribbean colonies. The MAJORITY of Caribbean black slaves were purchased by the Spanish, Dutch and French.

Talk Amongst Yourselves:

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.